Every property investor comes to us with a different set of concerns — but after enough conversations, the questions sort into four clear groups. Below are the real questions Central Indiana investors ask most, organized by where they're starting from, with straight answers to each.
Hear this whole topic discussed by host Jeremy Tallman and T&H Business Development Manager Jake Knight.
Here's how this year's new business breaks down by investor type, and the questions each group asks most.
56% New Investors
The short version: new investors are building a whole team from scratch — and the market, more than the money, is what trips them up first.
Where should I buy an investment property in Indianapolis?
The best area depends on your budget and goals, but strong rental demand, stable school districts, and steady city growth matter more than chasing the lowest purchase price. A local property manager can tell you not just where prices are low, but where properties actually rent quickly and hold their value — information that's hard to get from listing sites alone.
Explore neighborhoods on our interactive map →What does a property manager actually do?
A full-service property manager handles marketing and leasing, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, inspections, and compliance with fair housing and landlord-tenant law. The goal is a single point of contact who removes the day-to-day work of owning a rental, rather than an owner having to coordinate contractors, showings, and paperwork themselves.
See our full property management services →What do new investors underestimate about owning a rental?
Most underestimate ongoing maintenance costs and realistic vacancy timelines. Preventive upkeep — HVAC servicing, gutter cleaning, dryer vent cleaning — is easy to skip until it turns into a costly repair. Rehab and turnover costs have also risen well beyond pre-pandemic levels, which catches first-time landlords off guard when a unit needs work between tenants.
See the top 5 reasons investors fail →26% Frustrated with Their Property Manager
The short version: almost every transfer we take on traces back to one thing — not being able to reach anyone when it matters.
Why isn't my property manager communicating with me?
Poor communication is the number one reason owners switch property managers. It's usually a sign the company is understaffed, with one employee handling far more duties than they can keep on top of. If you're missing monthly draws, not hearing about vacancies, or can't get a call back, that's a legitimate reason to look elsewhere.
Why communication is a core value at T&H →How do I know if it's a property manager problem or my expectations?
Compare what you're being told against realistic market standards for rent price, vacancy length, and response times. If your property manager is meeting reasonable industry benchmarks and you're still unhappy, the issue may be expectations rather than performance. If you've already switched property managers more than once, that's usually a sign to reset expectations rather than switch again.
Is my property manager overcharging me for repairs?
Not necessarily — repair and maintenance costs have risen significantly in recent years, so a higher bill than you remember isn't automatically a red flag. Ask for an itemized explanation and compare it against a couple of other local vendor quotes before assuming you're being overcharged.
Why maintenance costs feel higher than expected →9% Self-Managers
The short version: it's rarely one bad tenant that pushes self-managers to hire out — it's running out of hours in the week.
When should I hire a property manager instead of self-managing?
When the time required to manage the property costs you more than a property manager's fee — in missed family time, job demands, or the stress of being on call for maintenance issues. Self-managers most often make the switch after a life change like a new job, a growing family, or owning enough properties that DIY management becomes unsustainable.
Do you really need to hire a property manager? →How much control do I lose by hiring a property manager?
You give up day-to-day decision-making, including informal arrangements you may have made with tenants. Property managers are held to fair housing law, which requires treating every resident consistently — so exceptions like flexible payment dates for one tenant aren't something a licensed manager can offer, even if that's how you ran the property yourself.
What a property manager actually handles →9% Converting a Personal Residence
The short version: keeping the low interest rate is easy — the surprise is how much higher the bar is for "rent-ready" than "sale-ready."
What do I need to do to turn my house into a rental?
Start with a property evaluation to confirm every major system and appliance is fully functional. Rental-ready condition is a higher bar than sale-ready condition, so budget for repairs and updates before listing it, not after.
What it costs to get your property move-in ready →Does a rental have to be as clean as a home for sale?
No — it has to be cleaner. Selling a home only requires broom-clean condition: personal items removed, no deep cleaning required, no obligation to update dated finishes. Renting a home is judged against hotel-clean standards: working appliances, no stains, no cosmetic shortcuts, because residents are paying to live there every month rather than buying it once.
See our property condition standards →Should I rent out my home or sell it?
That depends on your finances, not just your interest rate. You need reserves to cover a mortgage payment during a vacancy, and a willingness to keep investing money into the property over time. If you don't have both, selling is usually the better option than becoming a landlord by default.
Run the numbers with our ROI calculator →That's the real average time it takes to fill a vacancy — not the two weeks most landlords expect going in. A vacancy isn't just an empty unit; it includes estimating repairs, scheduling contractors, marketing the property, running showings, signing a lease, and the gap between signing and move-in. Fifteen days only happens when every one of those steps goes perfectly, back to back, which isn't the norm.
See how vacancy time affects your bottom line →The Common Thread
All four groups are really asking the same question in different words: is this a business I can actually run, or am I in over my head? New investors are learning the mindset from scratch. Self-managers are ready to delegate it but not the control that comes with it. Frustrated owners are checking whether their current company is running that business well on their behalf. Accidental landlords are deciding whether they want in at all.
None of that is a knock on any of them — every experienced investor started in one of these four spots. It's just a reminder that the questions worth asking usually come before the vacancy, before the surprise invoice, and before the call that never gets returned, not after.
Wherever you landed above, let's talk through it.
Talk to Our Team
