Where to Invest in Indianapolis: Carmel

Carmel, Indiana is a northern suburb of Indianapolis located in Hamilton County with an estimated population of 98,332.

And, before we go any further, Carmel rhymes with Marvel. Natives get pretty touchy about incorrect pronunciations.

Carmel has some pretty big claims to fame, being named one of the best places to live in the United States for multiple years, by multiple publications.

It’s known in some circles as the “Beverly Hills of the Midwest.”

It was platted in 1837, primarily settled by Quakers, and was originally called Bethlehem.

The name was later changed to Carmel in 1846 and officially incorporated in 1875. Carmel outline

Fun Fact: One of the first automatic traffic lights in the country was installed at the intersection of Main Street and Rangeline Rd. However, since the 90s, Carmel has been replacing intersections with roundabouts of which there are currently 125.

Carmel now has more roundabouts than any other city in the U.S. 

According to Data USA, the median household income is $109,201 with median home values of $320,400 and average rent amounts of $1150.

Niche reports 78% of residents won their homes compared to 22% who rent.

Niche also ranks it the #1 place to live in Indiana, the #1 place to raise a family in Indiana, and #1 school district in Indiana.

Carmel City Profile Report

Download as a PDF

Carmel, Indiana Zip Codes

  • 46032
  • 46033
  • 46074
  • 46077
  • 46082
  • 46260
  • 46280
  • 46290

Carmel, Indiana Neighborhoods

  • Brighton Woods
  • Bridlewood
  • Heather Knoll
  • Claybourne
  • Cedar Lake
  • Carmel Arts District
  • Woodfield
  • Village of West Clay

Examples of Homes T&H Manages in Carmel, Indiana

This 4 bed, 3.5 bath, 2,911 sq. ft. home that we manage is currently leased at a whopping $2,750.

4 bed, 3.5 bath home in Carmel, Indiana

On a very different spectrum, this 500 sq. ft. studio that we manage near the Carmel Arts and Design District is leased for $750.

Studio in Carmel, Indiana

Carmel, Indiana Schools

As you can probably guess, the Carmel school district is rated an A+ by Niche with the breakdown as follows:

  • Academics: A+
  • Teachers A+
  • Clubs and Activities: A+
  • Diversity: B
  • College Prep” A+
  • Health and Safety: A

There are approximately 16,034 students in grades PK-12th with a student-teacher ratio of 19-1.

It’s ranked the best district for Athletes out of 294 districts.

Carmel, Indiana Crime Rates

Best Places reports property crime in Carmel to be an 18 and violent crime to be a 7.1 based on a scale from 1 (low crime) to 100 ( high crime).

These are the lowest crime rates of any area we have discussed yet.


As you’ve probably already guessed, Carmel offers investors little to no hope of cash flow.

This is not an area that typically meets many investment goals.

While it’s obviously a very attractive market for Landlords from a Tenant quality perspective, the numbers rarely make sense.

As far as our brokerage experience goes, we haven’t assisted too many buyers with Carmel purchases and I don’t expect that to change anytime soon.

Written by Devon L. Hicks

As well as being a licensed Realtor, Devon has her Bachelors in Marketing from Missouri State University and utilizes her skills in a variety of ways to educate and advise real estate investors in the Central Indiana region.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.