60% of renters, statistically, will never buy a home. They don't save enough, they don't speak to lenders, and they're not watching their credit. For millions of Hoosiers, renting isn't a stepping stone — it's a permanent address. Here's what that means for your investment strategy.
Nationally, renter pessimism has hit historic lows. In Indiana, rising home prices and stagnant wages are compounding that despair into something structural. The investors who understand this shift — and position around it — are set up for durable, long-term returns.
This guide breaks down the data behind the renter-forever economy, what's driving it in Indiana specifically, and the exact implications for property investors in 2026 and beyond.
How Many Renters Actually Plan to Buy a Home?
The share of renters who believe homeownership is in their future has collapsed — and the most recent data makes it worse. A December 2025 Zumper survey of more than 6,000 renters found that three in four renters said 2025 was not a good time to buy a home, and that homeownership is increasingly no longer seen as part of the American dream — a stark shift from 2021, when only 27% felt that way. A separate Bright MLS survey of more than 3,000 consumers in December 2025 found that nearly 23% of renters under 40 say they do not plan to buy a home or are unsure they ever will — up from 18% just a year prior. And according to the National Association of Realtors, the share of first-time homebuyers fell to a historic low of 21% between July 2024 and June 2025, while the average age of a first-time buyer climbed to 40 years old — an all-time high.
What's striking isn't just the direction of the trend — it's the speed. The renter-forever mindset is accelerating into 2026. A May 2026 ConsumerAffairs report found that nearly 6 in 10 renters don't believe they'll ever own a home — with 56% saying homeownership feels unattainable at any point in their lifetime, and over 80% saying they simply cannot afford to buy a traditional home. An April 2026 Entrata survey of more than 2,000 renters found that 81% of renters say renting is now the smarter financial move — up from 72% among Gen Z renters just a year prior — and that 51% expect to still be renting ten years from now. Meanwhile, a February 2026 NAR survey found that only 17% of Americans say now is a good time to buy a home, down from 69% in 2013. The path to ownership hasn't just narrowed — for most renters, it has effectively closed.
Related: Indianapolis Market Updates for Investors T&H Realty's ongoing coverage of Central Indiana market conditions, rent trends, and investment strategy →What Are the Biggest Barriers Preventing Renters From Buying?
Financial obstacles dominate — but lifestyle and psychology are playing a growing role. Two-thirds of renters say they can't afford a down payment. But 70% say they feel relieved to avoid the burden of home maintenance. This isn't just economic defeat. For a growing share of renters, it's a genuine, deliberate lifestyle choice.
Multiple responses were possible in source surveys. Percentages reflect share of renters citing each reason.
The NerdWallet 2024 Home Buyer Report found that 37% of renters plan to rent permanently — not because they've given up, but because renting now genuinely suits their lifestyle better than owning. This is a meaningful shift from even five years ago, when renting was almost universally seen as a temporary state.
How Bad Is Indiana's Housing Affordability Crisis for Renters?
Indiana looks affordable by coastal standards — but for Hoosier renters, the numbers don't work. Home values across the state have increased significantly since 2020, with estimates indicating a total appreciation of roughly 42% to nearly 47% by early 2026, while wages grew at roughly half that pace. The state's $7.25 minimum wage — unchanged since 2009 — means a worker earning minimum wage needs three full-time jobs to afford a two-bedroom rental at Indiana's fair market rent.
In the Indianapolis metro, homeownership now costs roughly 36% of median household income — nearly at the unaffordable threshold. Only Muncie and Terre Haute remained affordable as of late 2025. Meanwhile, rental vacancy in the Indianapolis metro hit a 15-year low of 4.2%, meaning renters can't easily find alternatives, let alone save for a down payment.
Central Indiana Investors React to Surging Costs T&H Realty's firsthand account of what investors are seeing in 2025 and how to respond →What Does the Renter-Forever Trend Mean for Indiana Property Investors?
The permanence of renting isn't a temporary condition born of a bad market cycle — it's a structural market reality. Here's how to read the signals and position your portfolio accordingly.
TailwindStructural rental demand won't fade soon
With the median first-time buyer now 40 years old and rising, the "temporary renters just saving up" window is longer than ever. Indiana is adding apartment units at its fastest pace since the 1970s, yet vacancy remains historically tight. This is structural demand, not a cyclical blip.
TailwindLong-term tenants mean lower turnover costs
When 37% of renters plan to rent permanently and 70% feel relieved to avoid maintenance responsibility, they're not restless tenants eyeing the exits. Long-term leases, lower vacancy, and reduced turnover overhead are the direct investor payoff of this shift in renter psychology.
InsightThe single-family rental is having its moment
Families who'd normally buy but can't are turning to single-family rentals — the only product that fits their space needs. Median SFR rent in Marion County hit $1,625/mo in 2025, up from under $1,200 in 2019. That's 35%+ upside in six years on one of the most stable tenant profiles in the market.
StrategyTarget workforce housing, not luxury
New apartment construction in Indiana skews heavily toward studio and one-bedroom luxury — averaging 41% more rent than pre-2020 properties. The under-served gap is 2- and 3-bedroom units for families earning $40K–$70K. Investors filling that gap face less competition and consistently stronger occupancy rates.
StrategyIndianapolis suburbs and secondary markets
Lafayette-West Lafayette is absorbing 48% of Indiana's new apartment supply. Suburban Indianapolis markets — Noblesville, Greenwood, Anderson, Whitestown — are seeing demand spillover from renters priced out of Marion County, with lower acquisition costs and healthy year-over-year rent growth.
StrategyLock in long-term leases now
A 2- or 3-year lease on a quality unit in a tight market is a real asset. Tenants who feel relieved about not owning and want long-term stability are your best residents. Attract and retain them with professional management, responsive maintenance, and transparent lease terms.
WatchAffordability ceiling on rent growth
With 70%+ of renters sometimes or regularly struggling to afford housing, rent growth will eventually hit a ceiling. Renters earning below $30K are already stretched dangerously thin. Pushing rents beyond what the local market can absorb risks vacancy spikes when the cycle softens.
WatchMulti-family supply is accelerating
Indiana has issued apartment permits at double its 20-year average for four consecutive years. Over-supply in specific submarkets — particularly luxury studios in downtown Indianapolis — could compress rents and cap-rates faster than expected in those micro-markets.
WatchPolicy risk and tenant protections
The Fair Housing Center of Central Indiana's 2025 report put renter exploitation in the spotlight locally. Junk fees, aggressive rent hikes, and absentee landlords are drawing legislative attention. Investors operating with aggressive fee structures may face meaningful headwinds from policy changes.
What Does It Actually Cost a Renter to Keep Waiting to Buy?
Many renters believe they're "saving up" even when the math works against them. In Indiana, every year a would-be buyer waits, the goalposts move. Here's what the numbers look like at a typical Indiana price point, using the 2020-to-now trajectory.
Monthly payments have nearly doubled and the required down payment has grown by nearly $5,000 — while Indiana wages grew only ~25%. A February 2026 Experian report noted that a Hoosier household needs at least $69,500 in annual income to keep a typical mortgage payment under 30% of monthly earnings.
How Well Do You Know the Renter Landscape?
What Should Indiana Investors Do Right Now?
Ready to Invest in Indiana's Renter-Forever Market?
T&H Realty has been managing Central Indiana investment properties for decades. We publish investor resources, market data, and strategy guides year-round — because great property management starts with keeping you informed.
Visit T&H Realty Services →
